The purpose of critical appraisal is to determine the relevance of the material collected in relation to the clinical question raised. In other words, does the evidence provide the answer to the question raised and how confidently can the evidence be applied to practice? (Source: Cleary- Holdforth J, Leufer T, 2008 ‘Essential elements in developing evidence-based practice' Nursing Standard. 23, 2, 42-46)
Once the evidence has been appraised, and the best available evidence selected, it must be applied to your local situation. How it is applied will depend on its relevance to local conditions. (Source: The University of Newcastle Australia, viewed online 18 February 2011)
Below is a list of questions you may ask to help determine how evidence applies:
To complete the cycle of practising evidence based medicine clinicians should evaluate their own performance, and this fifth step of self evaluation allows clinicians to focus on earlier steps that may need improvement in the future. Clinicians can evaluate their progress at each stage by asking some or all of the following questions:
Sources:
Straus, E and Sackett D L 1998, ‘Getting research findings into practice Using research findings in clinical practice' BMJ Vol.317 p.339-342)
Johnson, C 2008, ‘Evidence-based practice in 5 simple steps' Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics Vol. 31 p.169-170
Evidence-Based Practice, University of Minnesota Libraries, viewed online 18 February 2011
Evaluating evidence-based practice performance – (Article) By Michael L Green (Source: Evidence Based Medicine 2006; Vol. 11; pages. 99-101)